A second woman is suing Kaiser Permanente and a former podiatrist for $23 million. Judith Young alleges the doctor injected rubbing alcohol into her foot instead of painkiller before removing her toenail at the Westside Medical Center in Hillsboro.

Young's lawsuit says the medical mistake caused a chemical burn that killed the tissue in her big toe and fused her bones, The Oregonian first reported Wednesday, Nov. 11. The suit says she was unable to work for months and, almost 10 months later, is in chronic pain and struggles to walk.

Young's case follows a $13 million lawsuit filed in June by Sarah Blackman, who alleges the same doctor at the Hillsboro facility injected her with rubbing alcohol instead of the painkiller lidocaine. Blackman's suit says the rubbing alcohol destroyed tissue in two of her toes, leaving her in continual pain with trouble walking.

The two lawsuits together seek $36 million.

Both women visited podiatrist Colin Mizuo about a week apart in January 2026 to have ingrown toenails removed, according to the lawsuits. Young had one big toe treated. Blackman had two toes treated.

Blackman's suit says she visited the Kaiser Permanente Westside Medical Center on Jan. 29, 2026, for what should have been a simple toenail removal. According to her lawsuit, after screaming and crying when Mizuo removed her first toenail, she begged him to leave her second toe alone.

The suit alleges Mizuo told her she should "just get it over with" and that if she didn't hold still, the needle he was using could go through her toe. The suit says he rushed out of the clinic after the procedure.

Both women returned to the emergency room nine days after their procedures, according to the lawsuits. Young's suit says her foot was burning, throbbing and swollen. Because nothing in her medical file indicated the doctor had injected rubbing alcohol, emergency room staff diagnosed Young with an infection and sent her home with antibiotics, the suit alleges.

Her toe "continued to deteriorate and began to turn black, ooze, and the skin began to come off," Young's lawsuit says. She returned to the emergency room three more times over the following weeks as her tissue died, according to the suit.

Both lawsuits say the women learned about the mistake five to six weeks later, when the head of Kaiser's podiatry department called them.

Mizuo has since left Kaiser Permanente, The Oregonian reported. The Oregonian reported that he could not be reached for comment. Oregon Medical Board records show no closed malpractice claims on file for Mizuo.

The Oregonian reported that Kaiser Permanente spokesperson Debbie Karman declined to comment on Blackman's lawsuit when it was filed. In response to Young's case, Kaiser spokesperson Karen Vitt said in a statement Nov. 10 that the company will carefully review Young's care "and take appropriate steps to address any issues identified."

Tigard attorney Laura Kalur filed both lawsuits. Young's husband, Thomas Young, is also listed as a plaintiff, with the suit alleging her injuries have "profoundly disrupted the parties' shared daily life."

The Oregon Medical Board can be reached at 971-673-2700.